On March 12, 2025, General Maruli Simanjuntak, the Chief of Staff of the Indonesian Army, addressed the ongoing debate about the placement of active military personnel in civil positions. He emphasized that this topic, related to the revision of the TNI Law, should not be overly contentious. Why is this issue stirring such strong opinions?
- TNI Chief Maruli Simanjuntak's remarks on civil roles
- Discussion on active military officers' placements
- Concerns over TNI's return to New Order era
- Criticism of those opposing military civil roles
- Revisions expand TNI roles in government agencies
- New agencies included in TNI's active roles
Understanding the Debate on TNI Personnel in Civil Positions
Why is the placement of TNI personnel in civil roles causing such a stir? General Maruli Simanjuntak insists that the discussion should focus on the facts rather than heated opinions. The revision of the TNI Law aims to expand the roles available to active military personnel in government positions, which has sparked concerns about military influence in civilian affairs.
What Changes Are Proposed in the TNI Law Revision?
The proposed revision to the TNI Law seeks to broaden the scope of ministries where active military personnel can serve. Currently, the law allows TNI members to hold positions in ten specific ministries related to national security and defense. The revision would increase this to fifteen ministries, including new roles in disaster management and maritime security.
Key Ministries Affected by the TNI Law Revision
With the proposed changes, several new ministries will be included for TNI personnel placements. This raises questions about the balance of power between military and civilian sectors.
- Kementerian Kelautan dan Perikanan (Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries)
- Badan Nasional Penanggulangan Bencana (National Disaster Mitigation Agency)
- Badan Nasional Penanggulangan Terorisme (National Counter-Terrorism Agency)
- Kejaksaan Agung (Attorney General’s Office)
Concerns Over Military Influence in Civil Governance
General Maruli expressed concern that the debate surrounding military placements in civil roles may undermine the integrity of the TNI. He pointed out that similar practices in other institutions do not receive the same scrutiny. This raises the question: Are these concerns about military influence valid, or are they unfounded fears?
The Future of TNI Personnel in Civil Roles
As discussions continue, the TNI remains committed to following the government’s decisions. General Maruli reassured the public that the TNI would adhere to any outcomes from the law revision discussions. How will this impact the relationship between military and civilian sectors in Indonesia?
